Vivarium Forum: Animal Welfare and Facility Design By Chris Cosgrove September/October 2004
Normally, this column attempts
to address specific design and constructability issues as they relate to animal
facilities; however, there is one issue that any of us working in this industry
have to deal with, and it just so happens that it impacts the way we design
facilities as well. This issue is animal welfare and animal rights groups. In
addition to the security concerns they raise, guidelines and regulations focused
on animal welfare, environmental enrichment, and socialization have been
evolving and expanding over the last decade and these changes can have an impact
on the design of the facility.
For example, exercise areas may be provided for group housing and
socialization of canines or non-human primates. These spaces may be in addition
to the holding rooms in which they are kept and can increase the size and
configuration of the building. In some cases, these areas may include outdoor
enclosures in order to allow the animals to have access to natural light and
fresh air. Most animals live naturally in social groups and, when possible,
facilities should be designed to accommodate these types of housing situations.
There are facilities that have opted for housing animals in social groups
directly on the floor of holding rooms, in some cases utilizing contact bedding.
In other cases, custom caging is employed to allow for the housing of large
groups within a room.
Many animals enjoy having a vertical environment in which to live as opposed
to the mostly two-dimensional environments provided by traditional housing
units. These vertical environments can be created through the use of resting
benches, shelving, slings, and other devices mounted to the walls. Connecting
tunnels have also been successfully employed to allow animals to be able to move
from one cage to the next and to give them a more three-dimensional view of
their world.
As the design of animal facilities has more to do with the processes that
take place within them than with anything else, careful attention must be paid
to the husbandry concerns of any new housing methodology. How will the bedding
and waste be handled? Should there be drains? Many of the methodologies for
these housing configurations still have to be harmonized into ìbest practicesî
and so may be experimental. Ensuring the room has the appropriate architectural
and engineering features to make it flexible and adaptable should be considered
as a way to minimize risk.
One of the most important forms of environmental enrichment that can be
provided to animals is actual human contact and interaction. Some facilities
have adopted the practice of allowing their staff time to do nothing more than
play and socialize with animals in their facilities. These interactions benefit
not only the animal but the staff as well. Providing these types of environments
can impact the ability for the facility to attract and retain qualified staff as
well as improve morale. Staff will have a tendency to take a greater sense of
pride and ownership in their work. This can create a less stressful work
environment and if employees are less stressed, it translates that the animals
will be less stressed. Remember, creating appropriate spaces within the facility
for the human occupants is just as important.
One option for increasing the interaction between animals and staff members
has been to employ walls made of glass, Plexiglas, or similar material which
allows animals to be viewed from the corridors. In fact, except for the diurnal
cycle requirements of rodents, there are few species for which windows could not
be provided within their holding rooms and one can always use closures and
coverings of various types to block light as needed.
As a word of caution, one must always be aware of the impact any change in
the animalsí environment has on research. After all, lab animal science is the
study of the effect internal and external stimuli have on the physiology and
behavior of animals. Any change in the animalsí environment could have an impact
and should be well conceived and controlled. Some might argue the changes are
purely for anthropomorphic reasons and that there is no scientific basis or
merit for it. This may be true; however, whether we like it or not, the general
public does think in anthropomorphic terms.
The general public accepts that animal research is needed. It is the way in
which animals are housed and treated that activists focus on with their outdated
and sensational campaigns, playing on anthropomorphic feelings. Unfortunately,
it may not be enough to show pictures and tell stories of the countless ways in
which animal research has helped billions of people over the years. Maybe in
looking for ways to augment our current education and awareness campaigns with
demonstrations of how research animals are housed humanely and treated with the
respect they deserve is something to be considered - and how we design our
buildings can have a role in that effort.
Institutions could opt to design their facilities such that they are
conducive not only to the welfare of the animals but so the facilities are more
friendly to the general public, even creating spaces where visitors can view
animals in the facility without actually coming into contact with them. Exercise
and group housing areas probably provide better opportunities than procedure
rooms, but why not show off that two million dollar robotic cage wash area via a
glass partition as an example of how facilities have moved into the 21st
century? Just imagine the impact of seeing staff and dogs playing and running
around each other can have and what a stark contrast it is to how activists
portray animal research. Such facilities also provide a way to educate other
employees so they can take pride in the way their organization treats animals in
research. The public is looking for a way to feel good about animal research.
They know this research exists, and hiding it can create uneasiness. As they
become more educated, see the advances made and the respect with which animals
are treated today, they may become stronger allies in reducing the tolerance for
the extremist positions taken by animal activists.
Want to advertise in the space above? Click here to contact a salesperson today!